7 min read

#522 – Sounds like AI...

There seems to be something going around at the minute when it comes to creatives clarifying AI's place in our artistic enterprise.


πŸ’°
BLACK FRIDAY POST DEALS ARE HERE.

(More on this next week...)

Two Editors Email about AI

A very experienced editor I respect emailed me on the back of last week's Cut/daily:

I love what you do but I urge you not to promote generative AI. As well as the environmental impact, increased use of AI will take jobs away from people.

Like the one you just promoted that will screw assistant editors, many of whom love creating sound for our cuts.

β€” Hollywood film and TV editor

This is the kind of email I love to get - someone who cares enough to critique!

After several days of thinking, here was my response:


I've long thought, and argued, and written about how I think we're still in the 'Clip Art' age of AI.

One where the people who always could hire an illustrator, editor, writer etc are still more than likely to do so because they understand and appreciate all of the knowledge, skill, taste, experience that the person brings to the job.

That's what they're paying for because they appreciate the results and the process with a human collaborator.

The people who used clip art in their designs, or now lean on low effort AI slop are not the same as the first group of people. They wouldn't have hired someone because they either don't have the budget or don't understand the difference.

Unfortunately, this is likely the bulk of the Gen-AI we all see - low cost ads, fake UGC content, posters for the school play, local takeout menus etc. the sloppy deluge of indifference.

So I feel like my reflex would be to disagree specifically that generative AI sound effects and Gen-AI per se will take jobs from assistants, in that those assistants are hired on productions who can afford them and hire them for a lot more tasks and responsibilities besides and by people who appreciate having a person around to do those things for them.

Will those assistants have either 'less to do' because they can do the same tasks faster with AI (syncing, spreadsheets etc), or more time to do other value-add tasks that they couldn't have done before?

This recent article in Variety with a survey of ACE editors (conducted by Avid) - looks like they're trying to put some data behind the anecdotal evidence of what's happening on the ground.


Variety reports on Avid's survey of 10% of ACE editors on their current use of AI:

  • helping with transcription (60%)
  • audio cleanup (55%)
  • searching for specific shots within hundreds of hours of footage (39.2%)

Choice quotes in the article from Editor Molly Shock include:

β€œWe do recognize it’s not going away,” she said. β€œYou adapt or die. So that’s a pretty big incentive.”

β€œWe the editors understand that this AI could be a really cool tool,” she said. β€œWe just want to make sure we’re included in the conversation of how it’s going to be used, and we’re not just thought of as a button-pusher and, β€˜OK, we can just replace this person with a program,’ because we do so much more than that.


[My rambling email continues...]

Now I'll stop here to point out the patently obvious that you will know far better than I (given that you're the one who actually works in US film and TV!) the reality on the ground for the assistant editors today.

What is it that you're seeing - are productions saying 'We're not going to hire an assistant - just use AI instead?

Given the toothpaste is out of the tube I think it's hard not to accept this new reality and yet try to shape how it evolves through hands-on experience and understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of this new technology. (Hence why I try these tools and write about them.)

Because in my experience these tools really are quite limited.

Sound effects are a case in point where the results are often not really ready for prime time in my estimation. I can see using them for placeholders - much like temp score is a placeholder - but even that still takes someone to select, create, edit, craft, massage etc. it's not a one click process.

I've seen demos (of different SFX AI software) where a car skidding on gravel was given a 'rubber screeching sound' that the instructor deemed 'pretty good' - which just goes to show that they either don't understand physics, or for the sake of the demo, don't care.

But a producer on a show at the level of hiring an assistant editor would care. And would care about consistency, accuracy and reliability.

So while the toothpaste is irreversibly out of the tube, its effectiveness and selected place in the workflow, is still in the hands of those who wield it. (To mix metaphors.)

Anyway, that's my 2-very-rambling-cents, I'd love to hear your thoughts on all this. And set me straight where you disagree. 

Jonny

The rest of this post is waiting for you when you subscribe for free, plus you'll get a free issue of Cut/daily in your inbox every Friday!